Welcome to

Mr. Nick's Pizzeria &
Italian Restaurant

Whether you’re looking for a cozy dine-in experience, a quick pick-up order, or the convenience of free delivery, Mr. Nick’s is your go-to destination for satisfying your cravings.

Book Online, Anytime

Book A Table

Monday : Closed
Tuesday – Saturday : 11:00AM – 10:00PM
Sunday : 12NOON – 9:30PM

Wanna eat something ?

The Menu

About Us

A Family Story

Welcome to Mr. Nick’s Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant, a Tarrytown gem proudly serving the community for over 15 years! Nestled at 19 N Broadway, our family-run establishment has become synonymous with delicious pizza, authentic Italian cuisine, and warm hospitality. Whether you’re looking for a cozy dine-in experience, a quick pick-up order, or the convenience of free delivery, Mr. Nick’s is your go-to destination for satisfying your cravings.

Mr. Nick’s has been a beloved part of the Tarrytown culinary scene since 2007. Founded on a passion for quality ingredients and a commitment to traditional recipes, our pizzeria and Italian restaurant have stood the test of time, becoming a cherished gathering spot for families, friends, and pizza enthusiasts alike.

Our Restaurant

Diverse Menu

At Mr. Nick’s, we take pride in offering a diverse menu that caters to all tastes. From our mouthwatering pizzas, crafted with the finest ingredients and crispy, hand-tossed crusts, to our authentic Italian dishes that capture the essence of homemade goodness, every bite is a celebration of flavor. Explore our extensive menu featuring classic pastas, hearty sandwiches, fresh salads, and more – all prepared with love and served with a smile.

Thanks to You

Our Reviews

This pizza place is the best. I know people often say that about their favorite place, but I have literally gone on a hunt for the best pizza in the Lower Hudson Valley, and THIS IS IT. The staff are incredibly helpful and friendly and remember who you are and what you like. This is a wonderful spot with amazing food. Must try!

We have been eating at Mr. Nick’s for the last 12 years and are so excited that they expanded and are open again. Now there is a bar and a sit down service restaurant in the back with a very nice atmosphere, excellent cocktails and an elevated menu. The back restaurant menu adds a little flair and complexity to the old favorite homestyle dishes view more

We enjoyed Mr. Nick’s: the food was excellent, the surroundings were very pleasant, but, more than anything else, the staff was friendly and accommodating. We were getting together with friends we hadn’t seen in a while, and some of our party had trouble deciding what to order from the extensive menu. 

oh Mr. Nick’s how I love thee! I’ve been living in Tarrytown for 10 years and when I moved here from Brooklyn, the hunt for good pizzeria food began. Thanks to the Halloween parade, my family and I stumbled into Mr. Nick’s and never looked back. The pizza is delicious, their Italian food flavorful. I’ve tried almost everything on view more

N W
Stay Up to Date

News in Our Restaurant